FPJ Legal: Bombay HC grants relief to men booked for abetting suicide of rape accused

FPJ Legal: Bombay HC grants relief to men booked for abetting suicide of rape accused

Narsi BenwalUpdated: Monday, August 30, 2021, 07:19 PM IST
article-image
Bombay HC | File Photo

MUMBAI: The Bombay High Court bench of Justice Surendra Tavade at the Aurangabad seat, last week, dropped charges of extortion and abetment of suicide against two men, booked for the suicide of a rape accused.

The bench was hearing a petition filed by Ramdas Mohite (60) and Suryaprakash Giri (49) challenging the charges of extortion and abetment to suicide, framed against them by a sessions court in Latur.

The duo was booked by the Latur Police on a complaint filed by one Mainabai Hanvate, alleging that they demanded Rs 500 from her to get the arrest warrant issued against her son, cancelled. Her son was booked in a rape case and was apprehending his arrest.

According to Hanvate's complaint, the duo came to her house in September 2011, and informed her that an arrest warrant has been issued against her son. They demanded Rs 500 from her to get the said warrant cancelled.

In her plaint, Hanvate further alleged that they again visited her house and this time assaulted her son and even threatened him. They further demanded Rs 1,000.

However, her son committed suicide two days later by hanging himself on a tamarind tree outside their house. She claimed that the duo instigated him and compelled him to commit suicide by harassing him.

The bench noted that the contention of beating up her son by the accused was an afterthought as the statements of a few witnesses suggested that the deceased was with his friends prior to committing suicide.

"Even if it is presumed that the accused had visited Hanvate's house, then also it does not establish that they had aided or abetted her deceased son to commit suicide," Justice Tavade noted.

"In the FIR, Hanvate has simply stated that the accused had demanded money and asked her to get the warrant of her son cancelled. It is also alleged that they were harassing her. Even if, the said statement is taken as it is, it does not disclose that they had in any way or in any manner instigated or aided the deceased to commit suicide," the bench said, adding, "There was no active or positive role played by the accused in committing, instigating or abetting the deceased to commit suicide."

As far as the charge of extortion is concerned, the bench said that the charge wasn't established even prima facie.

"At the most it can be said that the applicants had demanded money for giving information of issuance of warrant against the deceased. If the facts of the case are taken as it is, these cannot fall under the definition of extortion. Therefore, the offence of extortion is also not made out against the applicants," the judge said while discharging the duo.

RECENT STORIES

Ahmedabad Plane Crash: Air India Bird Strike Triggers Fresh Alarm Over Illegal Slaughter Near Navi...

Ahmedabad Plane Crash: Air India Bird Strike Triggers Fresh Alarm Over Illegal Slaughter Near Navi...

Mumbai News: BMC Constructing 6,731 Flats Across 5 Buildings In Mulund For Project-Affected People;...

Mumbai News: BMC Constructing 6,731 Flats Across 5 Buildings In Mulund For Project-Affected People;...

VIDEO: Congress MLA Nana Patole Sparks Row Over 'Operation Sindoor' Remark, Compares Indian Army...

VIDEO: Congress MLA Nana Patole Sparks Row Over 'Operation Sindoor' Remark, Compares Indian Army...

Mumbai ATS Busts Illegal Arms Racket In Dombivli; 2 Arrested, 4 Firearms And 35 Live Cartridges...

Mumbai ATS Busts Illegal Arms Racket In Dombivli; 2 Arrested, 4 Firearms And 35 Live Cartridges...

Mumbai Crime: Security Guard Arrested For Sexually Abusing 3 Minor Girls In Parel Building; Case...

Mumbai Crime: Security Guard Arrested For Sexually Abusing 3 Minor Girls In Parel Building; Case...